Failure to Assist and Hit-and-Run: When It Is an Offence and the Penalties
In this article
Key Takeaways
- Hit-and-run after an accident
- Manifest and serious danger
- The risk-to-oneself exemption
- Calling the emergency line
Art. 195 CP requires everyone to assist a person who is helpless and in manifest, serious danger, provided they can do so without risk to themselves or to a third party; anyone unable to give direct help must seek the help of others, for example by calling the emergency line. The most serious situation is leaving the scene after causing an accident (Art. 195.3 CP): where the accident was due to the fleeing driver's own negligence, the penalty reaches 6 months to 4 years in prison. Not every omission is an offence: there are exemptions such as risk to oneself or the effective presence of others already assisting the victim.
Need help with your case? Talk to a criminal defense lawyer at Alonso Sala.
The offence of failing in the duty to assist is one of the most serious offences against human solidarity. It is punished not for causing the harm, but for passivity in the face of another's suffering. As criminal lawyers experienced in the offence of failure to assist, we explain when this legal duty arises and the serious consequences of ignoring it, especially in traffic accidents.
The Basic Duty to Assist
The Criminal Code (Art. 195) obliges every citizen to assist a person who is helpless and in manifest, serious danger, provided they can do so without risk to themselves or to a third party. If they cannot give direct help, their obligation is to seek the help of others (call the emergency line).
Manifest and Serious Danger
A hypothetical danger is not enough. It must be a real, visible and serious danger to life or physical integrity. Ignoring a minor argument is not an offence; ignoring an unconscious person on the pavement is.
Hit-and-Run in Traffic Accidents
The most common and most severely punished situation is leaving the scene after causing an accident (Art. 195.3 CP). If the driver who causes the accident flees the scene knowing there may be victims, they face prison penalties of 6 months to 4 years. This aggravated form protects not only solidarity but also the driver's acceptance of responsibility.
Criminal Defence and Exemptions
Not every omission is criminal. There are clear exemptions:
- Risk to oneself: nobody is obliged to be a hero. If the help meant entering a burning car or jumping into a dangerous river, the omission is justified.
- Instant death: if the victim died at once, legally "there was no one to assist" (an impossible offence), even if it is morally reprehensible. This defence requires precise forensic reports on the time of death.
- Help from others: if, by the time you arrive, emergency services or other people are already attending effectively, your duty falls away.
Need a criminal defence lawyer?
If you are facing a criminal matter, our team of specialist lawyers can help. Contact us for a case evaluation.
Frequently asked questions
When is the offence of failing in the duty to assist committed?
When help is not given to a person who is helpless and in manifest, serious danger, where it could be given without risk to oneself or to a third party (Art. 195 CP). A hypothetical danger is not enough: it must be real, visible and serious for life or physical integrity. If direct help cannot be given, the help of others must be sought, for example by calling the emergency line.
What penalty applies to fleeing the scene after a traffic accident?
This is the most severely punished scenario. Under Art. 195.3 CP, if the driver causes the accident and flees the scene knowing there may be victims, they face prison penalties of up to 4 years where the accident was due to their own negligence.
Is it an offence not to help if doing so would put me in danger?
No. Nobody is obliged to take on a serious risk to themselves. If giving help meant, for example, entering a burning car or jumping into a dangerous river, the omission is justified. The duty to assist falls away when it cannot be fulfilled without putting one's own life or that of others at risk.
Am I still obliged to help if others are already assisting?
The duty to assist falls away if, by the time you arrive, emergency services or other people are already attending effectively to the victim. In that case, assistance is already guaranteed and there is no offence in not intervening personally.
What if the victim died instantly?
If the victim died instantly, legally there was no one to assist (an impossible offence), even though the conduct may be morally reprehensible. This defence requires precise forensic reports on the time of death to prove that it was immediate.
Do you need criminal defense in this area?
We are criminal defense lawyers specializing in failure to assist. We act urgently to protect your rights.