AS
Bufete de abogados penalistas Alonso Sala
psychology_altPractice Area

Instrumental Complaints

Technical defense against the spurious use of the criminal process. We protect your honor and parental rights.

arrow_backBack to Violence Hub

The Reality of Tactical Complaints

Although the system is designed to protect real victims, it is a forensic fact that sometimes the criminal route is used to gain advantages in family proceedings (use of the home, exclusive custody, alimony). We call this "instrumental complaint".

Our defense does not attack the victim, but the credibility of the account. We investigate the "spurious motive" (resentment, economic interest) which, according to the Supreme Court, is sufficient cause to doubt the truthfulness of the testimony and acquit for lack of evidence.

Digital Forensic Evidence

The best defense against a false word is an objective fact. We perform forensic dumps of mobile phones and clouds (iCloud/Google) to recover deleted conversations, audios, or locations that contradict the version of the complaint.

Example: If the complaint says you insulted and threatened her on a certain day at a certain time, and we provide a friendly conversation from that same moment or a GPS location elsewhere, the credibility of the complaint collapses.

Parental Alienation Syndrome and Manipulation

Often, the instrumental complaint is accompanied by a manipulation campaign towards the children to turn them against the father. Although "PAS" is a legally controversial term, psychological experts can identify and certify behaviors of "parental interference" or "induction to rejection".

Act fast is vital. If the false accusation manages to suspend visits for a year, the damage to the father-child bond can be irreversible. Our priority is to avoid that precautionary suspension.

psychology_alt

Why Alonso & Sala for Instrumental Complaints?

Specialized false accusation defense. Strategy: spurious motive + digital evidence + restore honor.

  • verified_userSpurious motive: investigate resentment/economic interest (divorce/custody). Supreme Court: sufficient to doubt testimony truthfulness = acquittal.
  • verified_userDigital forensic evidence: phone/cloud dump (iCloud/Google) recover deleted conversations/GPS locations contradict complaint.
  • verified_userSubsequent lawsuit: final acquittal → false accusation lawsuit (Art. 456 CP). Prison for her + moral damages compensation = restore honor.
  • verified_userPAS experience: psychological experts identify 'parental interference'/'induction to rejection'. Avoid precautionary suspension of visits (irreversible bond damage).
quiz

FAQs

How can I prove a complaint is false?expand_more
It's difficult, but not impossible. The key is objective evidence: recordings of prior threats, WhatsApp messages admitting a spurious motive, witnesses to the real conflict (e.g., infidelity that prompted the complaint), contradictory medical reports, or proof of a solid alibi (e.g., you were elsewhere).
If I'm acquitted, can I sue her for false accusation?expand_more
Yes, you can and should. Once you have a final acquittal, you can file a criminal complaint for false accusation (Art. 456 CP). This can lead to a prison sentence for her and moral damages for you. It's the only way to restore your honor.
What is a 'spurious motive'?expand_more
It's the term judges use for a hidden, fraudulent motivation to file a complaint. The most common motive is to gain an advantage in a divorce: getting the house, child custody, and higher alimony quickly and without argument.
If I'm acquitted, do I automatically get my house and kids back?expand_more
Not automatically. The civil measures (house, visits) adopted in the protection order are extinguished, but you must initiate a family proceeding (modification of measures) for a family judge to regulate the situation anew. The criminal acquittal is your best weapon in that trial.
Can the judge convict her for false accusation in the same trial?expand_more
Yes. If the judge sees 'patently and clearly' that the complaint was false, they can 'deduce testimonio' against her in the acquittal itself, ordering an investigation. It's the fastest and most forceful way to act.
What if her witnesses lie?expand_more
If the complainant's witnesses (friends, family) lie in court to corroborate her version, they commit the crime of perjury (Art. 458 CP), punishable by prison. A good cross-examination can highlight their contradictions and lead to them being investigated as well.
What if the complaint is archived for lack of evidence?expand_more
Provisional archival is not a full acquittal, but it frees you from precautionary measures. However, to sue for false accusation you need to prove the facts were LIES, not just unproven. It is an important technical distinction.
Can I record private conversations?expand_more
YES. Recording a conversation in which you participate is completely legal and valid evidence in criminal court, even if she doesn't know. It is the 'black box' that often saves the innocent man. Always record if you fear a false accusation.
Are private detectives useful?expand_more
Very. They can prove, for example, that she lives a normal life when claiming to be terrified, or cohabits with another partner in the family home (which could extinguish usage rights). Their reports are highly valued objective evidence.
If she withdraws the complaint in exchange for money?expand_more
It is extortion. If she asks for money or the house to withdraw the complaint, record it. It is definitive proof of the instrumentality of the complaint and a serious crime on her part.
Can I report her for slander on social media?expand_more
Yes. If she posts on Facebook/Instagram that you are an 'abuser' not guilty verdict, she violates your honor and presumption of innocence. You can sue civilly or criminally to delete content and claim damages.
Does this affect my job?expand_more
It could. If you work with minors or are a civil servant, a conviction (or even precautionary measures) can suspend you. That is why we fight to avoid the protection order and keep your presumption of innocence intact until the end.
What deadlines do I have to sue her?expand_more
The crime of false accusation prescribes in 5 years (if serious). You have time, but it is best to prepare the strategy as soon as the acquittal comes out.
Can the prosecutor act ex officio for false accusation?expand_more
They can, but rarely do unless scandalous cases. The Prosecution is usually corporatist and reluctant to pursue 'alleged victims'. It will be up to you, with your lawyer, to initiate the private prosecution.
If she self-injures to blame me?expand_more
It is crime simulation. Forensics can distinguish between aggression and self-injury lesions by the direction of cuts or blows. We need a strong medical expert report to unmask it.
What if police believe I am guilty from the start?expand_more
It is common due to protection protocol. Stay calm, do not testify at the station, and wait for your lawyer. The real battle is fought in court, not in the cell.
If I have witnesses who heard her plan the complaint?expand_more
They are pure gold. If a mutual friend or neighbor heard her say 'I will ruin him', 'I will say he hit me to keep the house', their testimony destroys her credibility.
Who pays my lawyer if I am acquitted?expand_more
If there is a conviction in costs to the complainant (for recklessness or bad faith), she must pay your lawyer and solicitor fees. We will fight for it.

Need Immediate and Expert Legal Assistance?

The judicial system is complex and can be relentless. Do not face it alone. We have the experience, technical knowledge, and human resources necessary to fight for you. Contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation and start building your defense.

Contact Alonso Sala

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing to browse, you accept our privacy policy.